The Maxwell School
Syracuse University
Syracuse University
# Power Plant Analysis ## Question 1: no carbon tax If it were certain there would **not** be a carbon tax, which plant would be better: the standard version or the CCS plant? The standard version is better. Explanation (not required): It has an NPV of $1015.5M and an IRR of 17.9%. The CCS plant is lower on both measures: it has an NPV of $536.5M and an IRR of 11.6%. ## Question 2: certain carbon tax If it were certain there **would** be a carbon tax, which plant would be better: the standard version or the CCS plant? The CCS plant is better. Explanation (not required): Its NPV of $536.5M and IRR of 11.6% are both better than the standard plant under a certain carbon tax: $175.5M and 9.1%. ## Question 3: 50% chance of a carbon tax If there is a 50% chance of a carbon tax, which plant would be better: the standard plant or the CCS version? The standard plant. Explanation (not required): The expected NPV of the standard plant is $595.6M and its IRR is 14.5%. Both are better than the CCS plant.